Friday, April 9, 2010
My Review of First Language Lessons for the Well-Trained Mind
The Old Schoolhouse offers high praise for First Language Lessons while I've read some individuals say who feel that it's too slow and boring. I'll just tell you what I think.
First as a mother of a 5 year old, first-grader, this book is perfect. The lessons are short and offer a lot of review. Each lesson is fully scripted which could be a benefit for those that might be a little afraid of teaching grammar. The lessons cover nouns, pronouns, verbs, sentences, poems, and more and offers copy work ideas as well. I appreciate how it demostrates that "classical" education doesn't need to be difficult nor tedious.
Personally, I rarely use anything as is and this was no exception, but to me, flexibility is one of the best things about homeschooling. I would often add more copywork than mentioned in the book. I also would occasionally do additional activities to support learning, as well. On the other hand, if I didn't think my dd another day discussing proper nouns, then I would skip that lesson.
Second, as a person who has taught "average age" first graders, as well, I have a slightly mixed opinion. If the only thing I was using was First Language Lessons, then I would say there might be concerns. The lessons as they stand would be enough to learn the "grammar", but I think being sensitive to the student would be required as well. Again, supplement or cut as needed. The lessons were not made to be exciting, but they are so short, they shouldn't be excessively boring either. The main thing I would definitely increase would be recommended copywork.
So, there you have it. I have enjoyed using this book and will definitely plan to use it for second grade. I haven't looked at the subsequent books, so I won't really comment on them.
- ► 2014 (132)
- ► 2013 (239)
- ► 2012 (399)
- ► 2011 (329)
- Field Trip Factory
- Found out about this really cool site from a loop...
- Books for Sale!!
- The Best Way to Punish Your Kids
- Copywork – What’s it All About? by Betsy Stout ...
- One of those days
- What Is Copywork?
- Homeschool Method: Narration
- Why a Schoolteacher is Quitting Her Job and Homesc...
- More Websites
- Free Printable Flash Card Maker.
- Weather Website
- Thanks to LeaAnn Garfias from Home Education on FB...
- An example of my adaptation
- The Theology of Crayons
- Happy Birthday, William Shakespeare!
- The Art of Retelling
- Four Hundred and Eighty-Nine Years Ago He Stood
- Home-schooling Does Not Hamper Socialization May ...
- Ode to Plurals---a cute email
- Feminism in Christian Colleges? Posted By Tiffany ...
- Ten American Girls From History---FREE
- Be Not Conformed
- Standardized Testing
- The Solution Isn't Just Bigger Consequences
- Teachers as Truth Brokers
- Important Constitutional Documents--FREE!!
- The Truth About Women that Feminists Don't Want Yo...
- Tim Hawkins
- Studying Plants in Science
- Home Schooler Gets Book Published
- My Review of First Language Lessons for the Well-T...
- Stupid in America
- What to Do When Kids Are Annoying
- Pizza Hut BOOK IT! Reading Program enrollment
- Awesome Opportunity for High School Students
- ▼ April (38)